Home      Why Dry Ice Blasting      Why IceTech       References      Videos     FAQ

Cleaning Comparison Charts: Methods & Issues

  Background Information:
blue arrow Dry Ice Blasting Benefits
blue arrow Dry Ice Cleaning Process
blue arrow Dry Ice Blasting Overview
blue arrow Comparing Cleaning Methods & Issues Charts

ICEsonic dry ice blasting has a significant number of advantages over other cleaning methods. Following is a chart that lists some of them:




Dry Ice Blast Cleaning Comparison Chart
Blasting Cleaning Technique
Waste for Disposal


Abrasive


Toxic

Electrically Conductive

Performance Comparison
Dry Ice No No No No Excellent
Sand Yes Yes No* No OK
Glass Beads Yes Yes No* No OK
Walnut Shells Yes Yes No* No Limited
Steam No No No Yes Poor
Solvents Yes No Yes Yes Limited

* Each of these blast cleaning materials becomes contaminated upon contact if used to clean hazardous objects. When that happens, these materials are then classified as toxic waste requiring safe disposal.



Cleaning Method Comparison
Issue Traditional Dry Ice Blasting
Equipment Downtime Cleaned in dedicated cleaning area; Disassembly/reassembly; Drying time required Equipment can be cleaned in place; Dry process - equipment restart immediately after cleaning
Hazardous Waste Cleaner becomes and treated as a secondary contaminant No additional contaminant; Dry ice sublimates with contact with targeted surface
Labor Hours Intensive hand scrubbing; Lengthy cleanings; Follow-up cleaning-up can be lengthy Dramatically reduced - often completed in a quarter of time or better
Quality of Cleaning Poor to average Excellent
Potential Equipment Damage Grit abrasions; Grit contamination; Movement of equipment to and from cleaning area No equipment damage; Preventive maintenance very realistic as labor hours are significantly less
Safety Health threats from solvents; Water-based cleaning pose hazards around electrical equipment; Threats to environment Standard safety precautions; Dry process - safe around electrical equipment
Cost Cleaner becomes additional hazardous waste; expensive solvents; Additional labor Minimal - cost of dry ice


 
blue arrow Free Info & Offers
blue arrow WATCH Dry Ice Blasting
blue arrow Equipment
blue arrow Rentals - Dry Ice Blasters
blue arrow Applications
blue arrow Download Documents
blue arrow In-House Cleaning Service
blue arrow Samples - Test Cleaned
blue arrow Demonstrations
blue arrow About C Three Microclean Corp


Quick Contact Form: